Are hopeful employees more innovative? A new study by Armenio Rego and his colleagues shows how employees’ sense of hope explains their creative output at work. They asked one hundred and twenty five employees to rate their personal sense of hope and happiness while their supervisors rated the employees’ creativity. Based on the correlations, they conclude that hope predicts creativity.
Hope is defined as a positive motivational belief in one’s future; the feeling that what is wanted can be had; that events will turn out for the best. Hoping is an integral part of being human. Without hope, tasks such as innovating become difficult if not impossible. Why bother if there is no hope for a successful future? “Hope is important for innovation at work because creativity requires challenging the status quo and a willingness to try and possibly fail. It requires some level of internal, sustaining force that pushes individuals to persevere in the face of challenges inherent to creative work.”
I have observed this in practice. I once facilitated employees in a division about to be sold to another company. The employees learned about the divestiture during the workshop. Morale was low, and participants were not responsive to systematic innovation techniques. They lacked hope…hope about their future employment and personal achievement. To salvage the workshop, we re-framed it. We told the employees they needed to innovate so that they would be perceived as valuable to their new owners. Innovating would give them an immediate jump-start on becoming competitive in the marketplace, something they struggled with under the current owner. Once hopeful, they kicked innovation into high gear. That workshop was one of the most successful and creative I have ever experienced.
What can leaders do to inspire hope? Darren Webb has outlined a useful model in his paper, “Modes of Hoping.” He identifies five types of hope:
Using this model, leaders can create hope at several levels to strengthen innovation:
Bottom line: don’t hope for innovation; instill hope instead.
Rego, A., Machado, F., Leal, S. & Cunha, M.P.E. (2009) Are Hopeful Employees More Creative? An Empirical Study. Creativity Research Journal, 21(2-3), 223-231.
Webb, D. (2007) Modes of Hoping. History of Human Sciences, 20, 65-83.
Innovation is a skill, not a gift. Top organizations drive growth by nurturing and investing…
Are you in the world of problem solving? Is problem solving a skillset you have…
5 Data-Driven, Customer-Centric trends we’ve identified This is not just another conventional forecast. Over nearly…
Imagine a chef, who only uses a spoon. Imagine a dentist, who only uses a…
In investing and business strategy, we often speak in terms of moats. Warren Edward Buffett…
This year, P&G’s Febreze celebrates its silver anniversary as a brand. But not all 25…
View Comments
Nice article, Drew. Unfortunately, I have to disagree with you a bit here.
I certainly do agree that morale and attitude have a direct impact on creativity, innovation, job performance, and a whole host of related metrics.
Hope, however, is a weak lever at best.
It's actually ironic you bring this topic up now, I just published an article in which I state that "Hope is a four-letter word" - we must have gotten the same writing assignment memo from the union muse. ;-)
(You can read my article here: http://bit.ly/qgwoM )
Hope implies a surrendering of control. "I hope my situation improves" casts fate to the winds, no matter what the scenario. I would go so far as to claim that you cannot have hope and empowerment together in the same action. You are either resolved to lead, or be led. You may arrive at the same place at the end of the journey, but only one path with teach you what you need to continue.
Jim, thanks for the comments as usual. 'Always like hearing from you. I enjoyed your post about this topic as well.
The type of hope you refer to is one of the five modes of hope. "Casting fate to the wind" sounds like the form of hope called "Patient Hope." You are hoping for the best in a general sense without any plan or objective in mind. I agree with you...this would be a weak lever of innovation.
The type of hope I think is most useful is called "Estimative Hope." This is when people feel empowered and have a realistic sense of the odds for achieving their goals. This would be a much stronger lever in my view.
I didn't realize the complexities involved with the concept of hope. I plan to do more reading about it.
(Apologies for the slow posting of your comment, Jim).
Since our discussion here in June, we've not only had a chance to meet in person, but I recently revisited this topic in a dedicated article that you might find of interest.
Great to finally have met last month in Boston, BTW.
http://andromeda-30.blogspot.com/2009/10/hope-is-four-letter-word.html
I don't think the title of your article matches the content lol. Just kidding, mainly because I had some doubts after reading the article.